Destination head-to-head
Cancun or The Florida Keys?
Cancun scores 7.7 out of 10 over a full year against 7.1 for The Florida Keys. Warm sea, short flights, all-inclusive value and a whole Mayan world within two hours.
Quick verdict
Cancun for all-inclusive, value for money, nightlife. The Florida Keys for easy and safe.
Cancun, Mexico
8.8/10
28C to 33C all year, sea 26C to 29C
The Florida Keys, United States
7.3/10
Overseas Highway, Key West and reef diving.
Rated side by side
Out of five on each criterion.
| What matters | Cancun | The Florida Keys |
|---|---|---|
| NightlifeBars, clubs and late-night energy | ||
| BeachesSand quality, water clarity and swimming | ||
| Food sceneRange, quality and local character | ||
| FamiliesKid-friendly resorts, pools and day trips | ||
| RomanceCouples, honeymoons and adults-only stays | ||
| Things to doExcursions, culture and day trips | ||
| All-inclusiveChoice and value of all-inclusive resorts | ||
| Value for moneyWhat a typical day actually costs | ||
| Easy and safeComfort for first-time visitors | ||
| Exploring soloHow easy it is to get out on your own | ||
| Flight accessDirect routes and flight time from North America |
Side by side
| Factor | Cancun | The Florida Keys |
|---|---|---|
| Daytime high | 29C | 25C |
| Rainfall | 60mm | 45mm |
| Sea temperature | 26C, swimmable | Varies by season |
| Beach quality | Wide white sand, calm Caribbean | 3 out of 5 |
| Getting there | under 5 hours from most of North America | Drive from Miami |
| Typical cost | All-inclusive value most of the year | Expensive |
| Between beach days | Chichen Itza, Tulum, cenotes, Isla Mujeres, reef snorkelling | No passport for Americans, Great diving |
Book your Cancun trip
- Check Cancun hotel ratesLive all-inclusive and boutique pricesOpen
- Browse Cancun toursChichen Itza, cenotes, Isla Mujeres and moreOpen
- Get an airport transfer quoteFixed price, 20 minutes to the Hotel ZoneOpen
Prefer a plan first? Build a free day-by-day Cancun itinerary.
Where The Florida Keys genuinely wins
- No passport for Americans
- Great diving
- Key West character
Pick The Florida Keys if your budget is open and you specifically want what only it offers: no passport for americans.
What catches people out
- Very expensive rooms
- Narrow beaches
- Peak season traffic
The Cancun edge
Cancun's beaches are wider and whiter, and a week there costs less than three nights in Key West.
Cancun is the rare beach destination that also works as a base. The airport is one of the busiest in Latin America, the transfer to your hotel takes twenty minutes, and within two hours you can be swimming in a cenote, climbing a Mayan pyramid, snorkelling the second largest reef on the planet, or eating cochinita pibil in a downtown market for the price of a coffee elsewhere. That combination is why we keep building these comparisons and keep reaching the same conclusion.
Cancun wins for you? Start here.